Skip to main contentSkip to navigationSkip to navigation
Amélie de Montchalin
Amélie de Montchalin said the EU would not be pressured into signing any deal by 31 December. Photograph: Kenzo Tribouillard/AFP via Getty Images
Amélie de Montchalin said the EU would not be pressured into signing any deal by 31 December. Photograph: Kenzo Tribouillard/AFP via Getty Images

Brexit: France says idea of Australia-style deal is 'for the birds'

This article is more than 4 years old

European affairs minister says extra six months may be needed to reach trade deal

France has mocked Boris Johnson’s claim that the UK can have an Australia-style deal with the EU after Brexit as “for the birds”, warning an extra six months may be needed to strike an ambitious trade deal.

Its European affairs minister told an audience in London that such a deal did not exist and it was time for both sides to realise the next phase of Brexit was “for people … not for politicians”.

Amélie de Montchalin also warned that the EU would not be pressured into signing any trade deal by an “artificial deadline” created by Johnson, and if Europe needed an extra six months to achieve a good deal for both sides then that is what should happen.

In a speech to Chatham House, she indicated that France was prepared to take a robust approach to the UK’s decision not to extend the transition period beyond December.

She said it would be virtually impossible to do a deal in 11 months if the UK were to diverge completely on regulations, as that would require a hugely complicated “line by line” negotiation on tariffs and border controls.

The only way to achieve a deal in the time given was through close regulatory alignment, she said, warning that a crash out would be the UK’s choice and not the EU’s.

“We are not ready to sign any kind of deal on 31 December at 11pm. We cannot let our level of ambition be affected by what I would call an artificial deadline. If the UK decides to shorten the negotiating period, it will be the UK’s responsibility. It will not be our choice on the European side,” she said.

The prime minister has repeatedly projected a readiness to crash out at the end of the year, claiming that if talks collapse the UK would at least have an “Australia-style deal”.

This has been rubbished by many who point out that Australia does not have a deal with the EU and therefore this is just a euphemism for no deal.

“The idea that they’re good to be an alternative to a free trade agreement, an honest level playing field, based on the Australia model (which by the way does not exist) is for the birds as you say in the UK,” De Montchalin said.

She mocked the UK’s rejection of the notion that the geographical proximity of the EU and the UK was a valid argument for a “special relationship” that did not look like a Canada- or Australia-style deal.

“Our future relationship will necessarily be a special relationship. You are not Canada, you are certainly not Australia, first of all because you can get here by train. You are the United Kingdom and no matter what happens the UK will remain a strong economic power on the doorstep of the EU, geographically and economically.

She said if the UK wanted a special relationship with the US it would still have to take account of the distance between the two nations.

“Paris and London are 300 miles apart. Boston and London are 3,000 miles away. It [a US trading relationship] could be more difficult,” De Montchalin said.

She emphasised the UK must remember that when it was negotiating with the EU it was negotiating with 27 member states, which like the UK were “sovereign” nations that had to protect the interests of their own citizens.

If the UK were to recognise that it was sovereign states in play rather than an enemy EU, then a space would be opened for a deal, she indicated.

Her remarks came as the government released its roadmap for negotiations with the EU over the next 10 weeks, disclosing the key areas they will be discussing during talks.

There will be five rounds of negotiations starting from Monday, with meetings alternating between London and Brussels and conducted in English.

On the schedule are talks covering 11 topics: trade in goods; trade in services and investment; a level playing field for open and fair competition; transport; energy and civil nuclear cooperation; fisheries; mobility and social security coordination; law enforcement and judicial cooperation in criminal matters; thematic cooperation; participation in union programmes; and horizontal arrangements and governance.

The thematic cooperation section refers to cybersecurity arrangements, as well as migration involving asylum seekers and those without the right to stay.

The “mobility” section will also look at arrangements that cover healthcare for tourists, short-term business visitors and making it easier for people who have paid into pensions in two or more countries to avoid dual social security liabilities.

David Frost, the UK’s chief negotiator or his deputy will lead the discussions on behalf of the UK and, after next week, rounds are scheduled for 18 March in London, 6 April in Brussels, 27 April in London and 13 May in Brussels.

As already briefed by the government a “stock-taking” meeting – at which point Britain could still walk away from talks – is planned for June.

The rights of British citizens in the EU and their ability to move between EU states for work, and short-term visas for travel are also due to be discussed. Wider EU rights were settled in the withdrawal agreement phase.

More on this story

More on this story

  • EU warns UK to tone down political rhetoric as trade talks start

  • Brexit: what are the key flashpoints as EU-UK trade talks begin?

  • UK to withdraw from European arrest warrant

  • UK says it will consider walking away from Brexit talks in June

  • Brexit: UK negotiating objectives for trade with EU, in a nutshell

  • I organised TV debates on Brexit. The ‘reasonable centre ground’ silenced itself

  • The Guardian view on food and Brexit: trust is not on the menu

  • Downing Street rejects EU's 'onerous' opening trade offer

Most viewed

Most viewed